I’m asking because everyone has an opinion, and since my opinion is more thought-out, and therefore better, than yours, I thought I’d discuss it. Again, I’m of two minds on the subject, so I’ll represent both of them here, in true CrossFire fashion.
Moderator Brent: Gentlemen, we’ve only got a couple minutes left, after that spirited discussion on what genre best represents Star Wars…
Right Brent–A sci-fi epic for the ages, Brent!
Left Brent–It’s fantasy, not sci-fi, you utterly ridiculous nerf herder…
Moderator Brent–Yes, yes, but okay now…Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull opens in theaters two weeks ago…what do you think, Righty?
Right Brent–It was a good movie, Brent. Not great, but good.
Left Brent–This was no heir to the Raiders Dynasty! It is a totally separate movie altogether! I don’t even want to hear the word Quadrilogy come out of your mouth!
Righty–Okay, true, but nothing could follow Raiders, quite possibly one of the few perfect movies in existence!
Lefty–All right, I’ll give you that. But instead of having another mysterious artifact that blows the imagination, like the Ark or the Grail, we get…what? Alien Skulls?! Thanks for giving the secret away in the first ten minutes!
Righty–Okay, but wouldn’t they just have been copying the formula? Didn’t you want a new movie? And that beginning sequence was fun and a great way to relaunch Indy for the next phase of life.
Lefty–And that’s another thing! He was SO OLD!
Righty–Are you mad that Indy aged? Or that you did? We love great characters–in our minds the single worst thing they can do is get old. It reminds us that we’re getting older too. So you can either go the James Bond route and recast Indy…
Lefty–Sacrilige!
Righty–…OR you let him get old and tell new stories from a totally new viewpoint. And admit it, no matter what the weaknesses in the movie, it was fantastic to see Harrison Ford back in the fedora. HE did a great job.
Lefty–Yeah, can’t argue with that.
Moderator–Okay, gents, out of time. What’s your vote?
Righty–Again, I wanted to love it, and I like it. Three arks.
Lefty–Indy’s back, but not better than ever. Two arks.
Moderator–For an average of two and a half arks. Go forth and enjoy!! And may I say, it’s nice to see you both agreeing about something for once.
Righty–(to moderator) You’re a ponce.
Lefty–(to moderator) And a dork.
RIghty– (to Lefty) Let’s go get some coffee.